You know, ive heard that it would be more logical if the ultimate expression of airbending was breathbending! In a way, its sort of like bloodbending because you could bend all the air out of someone and/or create an air vacum around them so they would start to suffocate. Or controling the actual oxygen in ones body like bloodbending. just a thought
Also, if that were true, no wonder all the airbenders we ever come across are monks and are against fighting; because if they were, they could kill you on the spot. Ultimate and utter decimation. nuff said...
i think any airbender that can make those little air balls that they usually ride on can suck the air out of you. I think flight should be the ultimate airbending technique. Its the most difficult to achieve after all.
And technically air is much more than oxygen, and bloodbending does control oxygen since water has oxygen in it. Airbending is more about creating/controlling air currents and wind i think
Very plausible. Except I think it could use a little refinement conceptually.
When we look at Fire and Earth; their purer refinements are extensions of their actual state of nature. Air turning to Sound is plausible. However, Blood shouldn't be the extension of Water. Replace Blood with Ice. Change Plant to LifeBlood. Plant Bending and Blood Bending followed the same concept. Both took control of the water within physical matter in order to control that object. Because Blood was replaced with Ice, doesn't quite follow as the intermediary between Water and Air, leaving a hole there. But my big thing is that Blood and Plant should be one in the same, and Ice should be an extension of Water, with Snow being unnecessary because it is ice.
A-M-A-Z-I-N-G Symbols. G-R-E-A-T Diagram. Just need to Iron out a couple of the disciplines.
wow, i never thought of it that way. you make some very good points. when my friend and i made this chart years ago, we were more focused on the show rather than actual logic. think of it like a leveling up system. level 1 waterbenders can bend water, ice, and everything inbetween. but it takes a skilled level 2 waterbender to be able to bloodbend, something most waterbenders are unable to do. just like how not every fire/earthbender can bend lightning/metal. soundbending was something we had to make up since we never saw anything past just regular airbending.
then there's the inbetween elements (snow, plant, lava, combustion). when we were thinking of what these inbetween elements could be, we thought more on the lines of "if we combined air and water, what would we get?" the same goes for water/earth, earth/fire, and fire/air. we chose snow for air/water based on what we saw in the beginning of the episode "Sokka's Master". we chose plant for water/earth for the episode "The Swamp". lava was from the Avatar short "Bending Battle" and combustion was thanks to Combustion Man (his attacks look like air that explodes).
thanks again for your input and i hope that i've clarified our reasoning behind our chart. maybe i should go back and add symbols for the other "elements" like ice and whatnot just for the fun of it.
AH YES i finally found this! I agree with the PlantBlood thing, but Snow/Ice is logically between Air and Water, and if you put that where Blood is, the entire chart loses its symmetry. I really wish Airbenders could bend ice, but they kind of get screwed over in the show with what sub-elements they get. Sound is definitely logical. I'm kind of confused on Combustion, though. Is that, like, explosions, or smoke? Or the Pokemon equivalent of Poison?
When I think of the sub-elements, lightning is between air and fire (because it's fire in the air), but the show did introduce it as a concentrated Firebending... I dunno, it's always the sub-elements surrounding Air that get confusing. But this is fantastic.
i like how you've got the spiral in the center of each symbol but have still made them both unique and related to each other. if i hadn't have watched the cartoon i wouldn't be able to tell your made up symbols form the real ones. nice work.
i like how u thought so well on this but would air and water make cloud bending and im sure earth and air make sand bending( i no its mostly earth but seems like air also from how the show depicted it)
Luckybaka I have been working on my own designs for the symbols representing bending types and wanted to know if I could use some of the ones you created in this new chart. Of course I would credit you with the original art for the ones I use in it.
On another note I was wondering what was your thought process behind the metal bending symbol for the bending art? The same question for combustion and spirit.
Did you do any other variations to the plant-bending one? If so what other designs did you think of for it?
Also I would value your input on this endeavor if you wish to give any.
while i'm glad at your enthusiasm for my chart and am glad you ask permission first, i'm gonna have to politely decline your request to use our designs. but i'm sure that if you put your mind to it, you too can make some very creative designs you can call your own.
as for our thought processes: Metalbending - it's supposed to look like a person that has their eyes closed, with the spiral representing their "inner eye" (kinda like what Toph uses to see). Combustion - i just wanted something simple looking that looked like i merged the symbols for Air and Fire. Spirit - if you look closely, you can see that it sort of resemble the yin-yang symbol. Plant - if we did have any other variations for this one, they are long since gone and i don't have our original sketch sheet.
again, thank you for asking permission first, but i'd love to see some designs of your own if you make any.